This is a table of the p-values of significance in their study and the p-values of the claimed replication in the UK Biobank:
As one can see, there is no p value of significance (5 X 10 -8 or lower) amongst the UK Biobank "replications." In fact, none is within 10,000 fold of a significant p value. Thus none of these were actually replicated. They are making hay of the fact that these p-values are in the same direction. Call it what you will, but that isn't replication.
No comments:
Post a Comment